Page 273 - kpi377
P. 273

Second  (as  already  discussed).  even  in  the  pre-reform  period.  China  made
                 major strides in enhancing and sharing basic social opportunities related to elementary educa-
                 tion.  primary health care. land reforms. and so on. This led to  significant achievements in the
                 raising  of the quality  of life  of the  masses.  including a  radical  expansion  of life  expectancy.
                 literacy.  and other elementary features  of good living. And furthermore.  when  the economic

                 reforms  came  in  1979.  China  was  well  prepared  much  better  prepared  than  India  to  have
                 widely  shared economic expansion and to  make use of the opportunities of globalization.


                           For every university educated person in China. India may have six. and yet as far as
                 basic  education  is  concerned.  India  with  its  sixty  percent  literacy  and  far  from  universal
                 coverage even among the young is  far behind China in not only enabling people to  read and
                 write. but also in giving the masses the opportunity to make use of the market economy. Based

                 on its  higher educational expansion.  India has  flourished  in many high technology fields  and
                 may  now  have become the second largest producer of computer software in  the  world  (next
                 only to  the United States). And yet these developments give little employment to  the masses.
                 in  the way  the  more broad based economic  expansion  does  in  China.  Correspondingly. the
                                                                              6
                 reduction of poverty has  been much faster  in China than in  India. The situation in  India is
                 changing now.  but still rather slowly.  and even  though India is  now quite close to  the  top  of
                 the league  table  of comparative economic  growth.  the  potential possibilities  of participatory
                 economic growth are very  much  higher than what has  been achieved so  far.



                 Shared Strategy Rather  than Asian Values
                           Thailand too has  followed  a path that has been much more productive in  making
                 use  of the  market economy than  India has.  This  is  not just because it has  given  more  room
                 directly to the market economy a correct diagnosis but on which must not be oversold to  the
                 exclusion of other contrasts. The broad base of elementary education is  quite central for  the

                 success  of the market economy in  a rapidly globalizing world.  and in  this  field.  Thailand has
                 been enormously ahead of not only India. but also  a great many countries in the third world
                 in  Asia  and  Africa.  The  focus  on  human  capability  enhancement  has  been  strong  in  the
                 modern economic history of Thailand.


                           Perhaps. in this context. I should comment briefly on an approach that has gained
                 some  currency  in  Asian  economic  thinking.  suggesting  that  the  so  called  Asian  economic
                 success  is  the result of some grand set of values  that go  by  the  name of "Asian values."  This
                 is.  of course.  a  modern  variant  of the  nineteenth  century  thought  that  it  is  some  special

                 "Western" value  that has made it possible for Europe and North American to surge ahead of
                 Asia  and  Africa.  It  is  worth  noting  that  while  values  at  some  general  level  are  undoubtedly
                 imprtant  in  the  success  of  the  market  economy.  the  grand  attempts  to  explain  capitalist


                           'On this see  Dreze and Sen. India : Economic  Devel0Rment and Social  0pRonunity (1995).  Chapter 5.
   268   269   270   271   272   273   274   275   276   277   278